The Voice UK coach Tom Jones – “X Factor judges don’t have enough experience”

The legendary performer says The X Factor is about "PR spin" rather than talent

Welsh singing legend Tom Jones says judges on The X Factor make bad decisions because they don’t have enough experience of the music industry.

Advertisement

Jones, 71 – who joins Jessie J, will.i.am and Danny O’Donoghue as a coach on BBC1’s upcoming new talent show The Voice UK – said The X Factor had failed to discover “stars with world-class voices” and that the show’s judges had made numerous wrong decisions.

“Every time I see one of these shows I think half the decisions are wrong and it really frustrates me,” said Jones.

“Some of the judges don’t have the experience to be on talent shows – if you’ve only been in the industry two minutes, how can you offer advice?” asked the singer, whose career spans five decades.

“I have the experience and I listen to all sorts of music, so the advice I give will be valuable,” he told The People.

Jones said he had agreed to join The Voice because he felt he could do a better job than judges on existing shows, and because its format – which features initial rounds in which contestants are heard but not seen – is about discovering real vocal talent.

“I got fed up with shows like X Factor and thought I better do one myself because the judging has been questionable. A singing contest should be about someone’s voice – not PR spin,” he said.

“I’m genuinely excited about The Voice – it’s exciting, competitive and compelling television because it’s all about talent.”

Jones is not the first UK Voice coach to openly attack The X Factor. Black Eyed Peas star will.i.am previously said he hoped former X Factor judge Cheryl Cole, who he manages, would perform on The Voice to “p*** Simon Cowell off.”

Start dates for the two shows have not yet been confirmed but reports suggest they could go head-to-head on 24 March.

The judging line-up for the new series of The X Factor is still to be announced but long-time panellist Louis Walsh has suggested that he, Gary Barlow and Tulisa will retain their places. Kelly Rowland is thought not to be returning.

Advertisement

The Voice UK is based on a Dutch format and is already a huge success in the United States.