Liar viewers suspect a third party may be involved in the mystery
But most of us are still as confused as ever

If you’re struggling to figure out exactly who is telling the truth on ITV’s Liar, you’re not alone (the clue’s in the title, after all).
During last night’s second episode, dozens of confused fans took to Twitter to share their bemusement, as each twist and turn knocked any preconceived ideas sideways. Is he lying? Is she lying? Are they both lying? What is truth anyway?
As surgeon Andrew dealt with the consequences of Laura posting about the alleged rape on Facebook, the lack of police action led the frustrated teacher to break into his house. And let’s just say, she isn’t quite cut out for the cat burglary game.
And after her discovery of a mysterious phial of liquid under his bed turned out to be a red herring, we’re still no closer to knowing the truth….
He's lying, she's lying, they're all lying, suspicious of all of them #Liar pic.twitter.com/zhRhnHKjUQ
— Mark Nice (@MarkNice2402) September 18, 2017
When you think you've worked out who's lying and then something else comes up and you're back to square one again #Liar pic.twitter.com/brhkSDywJC
— L A U R E N (@LaurenWelford) September 18, 2017
Trying to work out who's telling the truth #liar pic.twitter.com/pONqU4Zrnv
— Andy Martin (@__AndyMartin) September 18, 2017
Every time a character says something #liar #itv pic.twitter.com/4ED3SApxLY
— Stuks (@Superstar_Stuks) September 18, 2017
She's lying? He's lying? Or both of them? Or neither of them? #Liar pic.twitter.com/fVoiq62Fui
— Aishah Khan (@AishahKhan13) September 18, 2017
But a few canny viewers think they’re onto something – and they reckon that Laura’s sister Katie, who is having an affair with her ex-boyfriend, is connected in one way or another. She is an anaesthetist, after all…
SOLVED It was her sister! She wasnt raped. She's framing him!
Doesnt care about sister (due to affair),knew of whereabouts n had a key #liar— Craig Kimmitt (@craigpaul85) September 18, 2017
The sister is defo behind something #liar
— Jess Stevens (@jess_stevenss) September 18, 2017
The sister is fishy…. #liar
— Katie Addison (@katie_addison) September 18, 2017
Her sister is an anaesthetist – she could get hold of drugs that'd make her sister pass out… #Liar
— Sarah Capps (@nightflower2001) September 18, 2017
Hmm… We’re still stumped.
Liar airs on Mondays at 9pm on ITV