At San Diego Comic Con 2019, one of the biggest stunts didn’t come from Marvel’s smash-hit Phase 4 panel, or the Game of Thrones retrospective, or from some imaginative marketer on the show floor – instead, it came from the sky, specifically from a hired plane as it pulled a message through the sky on a banner.
“Release the Snyder Cut.”
For those not in the know, the message may have been confusing, but for those who’ve followed this unusual and protracted campaign for a while it came as no surprise.
The Snyder Cut refers to a near-mythical version of 2017 superhero movie Justice League, much different to the version that actually made it to cinemas. In August 2019, Aquaman star Jason Mamoa claimed to have actually seen this mystery cut, while his Worlds of DC co-stars Ben Affleck, Gal Gadot and Ray Fisher also called for its release,
Now, new rumours have surfaced that the Snyder Cut might finally get an official release on new streaming platform HBO Max – set to launch on the 27th May in the US – with fans speculating that Snyder himself will announce the news during a planned fan watchalong of Man of Steel on 20th May.
Many of us are struggling during this difficult time. Felt it could be cathartic to come together now for a Man of Steel Watch Party and celebrate the ultimate symbol of hope. Submit some questions, I’ll answer a few after. #manofsteel #superman https://t.co/PdvGayTe7b pic.twitter.com/GMvIWyD4y4
— Zack Snyder (@ZackSnyder) May 18, 2020
But does the Snyder Cut actually exist in any form actually approaching a finished film? And are we really, finally, about to experience the movie as it was originally envisioned?
The basic background to the conspiracy theory is that director Zack Snyder – who exited Justice League early following his daughter’s death – had finished a cut of the big-budget team-up movie, but jittery Warner Brothers executives decided to reshoot large swathes of the film after the poor critical reaction to Snyder’s previous movie in the series, Batman vs Superman: Dawn of Justice.
To be fair, some of this is definitely based in fact. It’s a matter of public record that Warner Bros brought on board Avengers director Joss Whedon to perform reshoots and rewrites to finish the film, and it’s fairly public knowledge that the film’s events and tone were altered significantly in the process – even if WB played down these concerns at the time.
“The directing is minimal and it has to adhere to the style and tone and the template that Zack set,” said then-Warner Bros Pictures president Toby Emmerich.
“We’re not introducing any new characters. It’s the same characters in some new scenes. He’s handing the baton to Joss, but the course has really been set by Zack. I still believe that despite this tragedy, we’ll still end up with a great movie.”
Scenes including an extended introduction to villain Steppenwolf (Ciaran Hinds), hints at the introduction of DC mega-villain Darkseid, an origin story for Ray Fisher’s Cyborg and others were reportedly (via Snyder himself) removed from the new version and new jokes and other scenes were changed or added. Some of this can be gleaned from watching the film’s original trailers, which often contain scenes and lines of dialogue absent from the theatrical cut.
But does all this add up to a big conspiracy?
Well, it depends who you ask. Dedicated Snyder fans maintain that the perfect, “true” version of Justice League does exist, and that if they argue loud enough Warner Bros will be forced to release it. These staunch defenders of Man of Steel and Batman vs Superman hope a version of Justice League exists that’s closer in tone to those releases, and believe they can bring it into the world through social media bombardment alone.
For his part, Snyder did eventually reveal that he’d left a 151-minute cut of the film behind when he departed the project (a notably longer version than the 120-minute film that was actually released, though also a notably shorter version than the 214-minute cut than had been rumoured by Snyder Cut campaigners) but despite fans’ beliefs, this version was almost certainly nowhere near ready for release, with few (if any) special effects scenes, sound editing or grading added and a lot of green-screen remaining.
— Geralt of Rivia (@itssan17) August 14, 2019
“The movie was still months away from delivery when Joss came on board,” an anonymous VFX editor told The Telegraph of the Snyder Cut.
“It seems very unlikely to me that there was anything close to a releasable cut of the film. Put it another way: if there was a near finished movie that everyone was happy with, then WB would have got the editor to complete it rather than drop another $30-40 million [in reshoots] into it.”
In other words, a “Snyder Cut” might have existed, but it would be impossible to release it without millions more dollars of effects work, and even then it might not be in a state that Warner Bros. would be happy releasing, especially considering the decidedly mixed reaction that the theatrical release received.
That, perhaps, could have been that – but in August, one of Justice League’s stars, Aquaman actor Jason Momoa, claimed to have seen the Snyder Cut and took to social media to extoll its virtues.
“Let’s be honest – if it wasn’t for this man, we wouldn’t have Aquaman,” Momoa wrote on Instagram.
View this post on Instagram
Well let’s be honest if it wasn’t for this man we wouldn’t have Aquaman I love u Zachary synder. Mahalo for showing me the synder cut. Here is a token of my appreciation. Leica Q2 for inspiring me as an artist through and through @leicacamerausa I wish I was a better actor but I can’t lie. The Snyder cut is ssssiiicccckkkkkk #luckymesucksforu #q2 #leicaforlife @cruelfilms aloha j
“I love u Zachary synder (sic). Mahalo for showing me the synder (sic) cut..[..]..The Snyder cut is ssssiiicccckkkkkk.”
Three months later and, within hours of each other, Batman actor Ben Affleck, Wonder Woman’s alter ego Gal Gadot and Cyborg star Ray Fisher all posted on social media demanding that the Powers-That-Be #ReleaseTheSnyderCut, in what appeared to be a organised campaign.
— Ben Affleck (@BenAffleck) November 17, 2019
— Gal Gadot (@GalGadot) November 17, 2019
So does a ready-for-release Snyder Cut exist after all? Clearly, something had to exist for Snyder to show to Momoa (assuming he wasn’t just joking) but was it a version that actually had effects and polish, or just a very rough outline that a fellow industry professional could appreciate?
Momoa just shut down every Snyder Cut hater (for now). Doesn’t exist? Jason Momoa saw it and gave Zack a sick gift for the honour. It’s gonna suck anyways? It’s SIIIIIICK. Jason is not holding back, this might be the biggest showing of support for #ReleaseTheSnyderCut we’ve seen
— GrayGhost84 (@grayghost84) August 19, 2019
We may never know the answer. Despite those HBO Max rumours, there’s still no concrete proof that Warner Bros would invest money into completing an alternate version of a film that they clearly thought wasn’t working, and Zack Snyder showing a rough cut to his (probably quite kind) friends doesn’t immediately mean that a recut rerelease would be financially viable.
But look, #ReleaseTheSnyderCut devotees can take some comfort from the fact that someone, somewhere got to live their dream, and enjoy a Snyder-approved version of Justice League.
And maybe, just maybe, they’ll find that the real Snyder Cut was the friends they made on Reddit along the way.
Find something to watch tonight with our TV Guide