Ad
Powered By
IMDB

Review

A star rating of 3 out of 5.

Following a disappointing Hollywood detour with The Tourist (2010), Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck returns to the domain of the Academy Award-winning The Lives of Others (2006) in this sprawling drama revealing how the German people swapped one form of totalitarianism for another in the middle of the last century. Yet, despite the best intentions of this Oscar-nominated film à clef about artist Gerhard Richter, the director's screenplay has a mini-series superficiality that's reflected in Caleb Deschanel's prettified images of life in Nazi Dresden, Communist East Germany and post-Berlin Wall Dusseldorf. At the heart of proceedings is Kurt Barnert (played as a child by Cai Cohrs), who is oblivious to the fact his beloved Aunt Elisabeth (Saskia Rosendahl) was euthanised by SS doctor Carl Seeband (Sebastian Koch), even after he grows up to be an art student (Tom Schilling) and falls for the ideologically flexible monster's daughter, Ellie (Paula Beer). Such convolutions add tension to the highly involving three-hour saga. But, considering so much emphasis is placed on the 1937 exhibition of "Degenerate Art", this is a dramatically conventional and alienatingly glossy chronicle of a turbulent time.

How to watch

Loading

Credits

Cast

rolename
Kurt BarnertTom Schilling
Professor Carl SeebandSebastian Koch
Ellie SeebandPaula Beer
Elisabeth MaySaskia Rosendahl
Professor Antonius van VertenOliver Masucci
Heiner Kerstens, exhibition guideLars Eidinger
Kurt Barnert, aged 6Cai Cohrs

Crew

rolename
DirectorFlorian Henckel von Donnersmarck

Details

Theatrical distributor
Modern Films
Released on
2019-07-05
Languages
German | Russian
Guidance
Sex scenes, nudity
Formats
Colour
Ad
Ad
Ad