We asked you what TV shows left us too soon – here's the graveyard of series needing resurrecting

Taken too soon, never forgotten. From fan favourites to cult classics, these are the TV shows that deserved more time on screen, as chosen by Radio Times and our readers.

Two suited FBI agents sit at a metal interview table in a secure room enclosed by chain-link fencing. The younger agent holds up a black-and-white crime scene photograph while looking ahead, as his older colleague watches from beside him. Notebooks and files are spread across the table.

Netflix

Published: Thursday, 23 July 2026 at 7:00 am

Subscribe to Radio Times: 10 weeks for £10, including the Christmas double issue

There are few things more heartbreaking than saying goodbye to our favourite TV shows – even when it's the right time to close the door on a particular group of characters.

Ad

But nothing is more gutting than seeing a great series with bags of potential cancelled before it gets the chance to bow out on its own terms.

For every show that deserved to be consigned to the scrapheap – or perhaps should never have been commissioned in the first place (Joey, we're looking at you) – there are those which were felled in their prime, or just as they started to hit their stride.

From cliffhangers that still keep us up at night to characters whose stories deserved another chapter, these are the shows that earned the right to return, as chosen by Radio Times readers, the Radio Times team and our trusted freelancers.

Home Fires

An outdoor market stall displays dozens of jars of preserves arranged across a table decorated with flowers, baskets, and greenery. A smiling vendor in a bright blue coat reaches across the table to hand an item, likely a receipt or purchase, to a customer wearing a green sweater, brown overalls, and a patterned headscarf, who stands beside a bicycle. Two other vendors stand behind the stall watching the exchange. A decorative fabric banner hangs behind them, and brick buildings and greenery in the background create the atmosphere of a village market.

Clare Calbraith as Steph Farrow, Claire Price as Miriam Brindsley, Claire Rushbrook as Pat Simms, and Ruth Gemmell as Sarah Collingborne. ITV

ITV period drama Home Fires received more mentions than any other title when we recently asked Radio Times readers which TV drama was cancelled too soon.

Set in the Cheshire countryside during World War II, Simon Block's series, based on Julie Summers's Jambusters novel, follows a group of Women's Institute members on the Home Front. It ran for two seasons between 2015 and 2016 before leaving viewers in the dark about who had survived a plane crash.

"When ITV chose not to re-commission the series, I was all set to take my characters through the next few months of their lives on the Home Front," Block said at the time. "Their stories were all planned, yet I was left with little choice but to accept the channel's decision."

Furious about its premature end, fans launched a petition that attracted more than 20,000 signatures, and it was also voted the British TV show most deserving of a revival in a Radio Times poll of 16,000 readers.

Eventually, Block did find another way to continue the story, writing a trilogy of novels, the first of which picked up directly after the season 2 finale.

But while readers appreciated finally getting some answers, it wasn't enough to make up for the axing.

"I had to buy the two books to find out what happened after that terrible cliffhanger!" one reader said, while another added: "They would have been so much better doing another series!"

Mindhunter

Jonathan Groff in Mindhunter

Jonathan Groff as Holden Ford. Netflix

Was the BTK strangler ever caught? David Fincher’s 2017 psychological series about the origins of the FBI’s behavioural science unit left many plotlines unresolved when Mindhunter was cancelled after just two seasons, including the fate of an infamous killer teased throughout the show’s 19 episodes.

Featuring superb performances from Jonathan Groff, Holt McCallany and Anna Torv, the series expertly mixed personal drama with gripping insights into real life murderers (Cameron Britton is chilling as Edmund Kemper). While five seasons were originally planned, due to high production costs and Zodiac director Fincher’s busy schedule, in 2023 he confirmed that no more episodes would be made. - Jo Berry, freelance journalist.

Reaper

A smiling person with short gray hair, wearing a black collared shirt and black jacket, poses against a bright red background. Mounted on the wall beside them is a large white theatrical mask with black horn-like points, gold-rimmed eye openings, and red-painted lips, creating a striking contrast with the person's cheerful expression. The image is a close-up portrait with both the person and the decorative mask prominently framed.

Ray Wise as The Devil. Kevin Mazur/WireImage for The CW Network

Youth-oriented broadcaster The CW (and its precursor The WB) had no shortage of dark fantasy content over the years, from Buffy the Vampire Slayer to Supernatural and The Vampire Diaries. Unfortunately, this addition to that pantheon managed to slip through the cracks.

Reaper follows university dropout Sam Oliver (Bret Harrison), who suffers a 21st birthday that can't easily be forgotten. Far worse than a misjudged night out, Sam learns that his parents sold his soul to the devil in his sickly infant years in order to keep him alive – now, as an adult, his servitude must begin.

What starts as a 'monster of the week' procedural – in which Sam hunts down sinister souls escaped from hell – later develops into an intriguing, serialised mystery that didn't reach its planned conclusion. Still, Twin Peaks star Ray Wise's darkly comic turn as The Devil is reason enough to tune in. - David Craig, Senior Drama Writer.

Whitechapel

A gray placeholder screen displays the message: "This image is unavailable because it is of an unsupported file type." The text is centered on a plain light gray background, with no other visible content.

Phil Davis as DS Ray Miles and Rupert Penry-Jones as DI Joseph Chandler. ITV

ITV crime drama Whitechapel, set in London's East End, follows a team of detectives investigating modern-day murders inspired by the area's most infamous crimes, beginning with a Jack the Ripper copycat.

"Phil Davis and Steve Pemberton were magnificent," said one RT reader. "The journeys through the bleak alleys were superbly done, and those stories were as dark as they get."

Another reader said they still wanted to know "what Angela Pleasence was up to!", while someone else added: "Phil Davis and Steve Pemberton were top notch, and Rupert Penry-Jones carried the series with a nuanced performance. Silly suits for cancelling it."

After four seasons, the series was discontinued in 2013 as ITV looked to refresh its drama slate.

"Whitechapel has been a successful drama commission since first broadcasting in 2009," the broadcaster said at the time. "The commissioning team continue to refresh the channel's drama portfolio, hence the decision not to commission beyond the fourth series."

It was a cruel blow for viewers who had been invested from the beginning, only to be left with unanswered questions and unfinished character arcs. Co-writer Ben Court also later revealed that they had a "great" final season planned, which would have uncovered who killed Penry-Jones's Chandler's father and finally "freed him from the generational curse" – making the show's cancellation all the more painful.

The Tripods

A towering three-legged alien machine looms over a wooded valley, while a small group of people stands gathered near houses in the distance under a grey, overcast sky.

The titular enforcers of The Tripods. BBC/YouTube

There was also plenty of love from RT readers for BBC sci-fi series The Tripods, based on John Christopher's novel trilogy about a world subjugated by towering, three-legged machines.

It ran for two seasons, with plans for a third, before being cancelled in 1985 due to disappointing ratings, leaving viewers with plenty of unanswered questions.

"I don't know about deserved, but The Tripods required another season," said one reader.

"I needed closure," agreed another, while a third added: "It needed season 3 to finish the story."

Fans did eventually get a glimpse of what might have been. When the series was released on DVD in 2009, it included a booklet detailing writer Alick Rowe's plans for the never-made third season.

But while that was better than nowt, it was no substitute for seeing the story play out on screen.

Freaks and Geeks

Jason Segel and Linda Cardellini in Freaks and Geeks

Jason Segel and Linda Cardellini in Freaks and Geeks. Chris Haston/NBCU Photo Bank/NBCUniversal via Getty Images via Getty Images

The best teen movie that's not a movie, this story of two siblings navigating '80s high school is just as relatable now as it was when viewers overlooked it in 1999.

Despite getting cancelled after just one season, Paul Feig's teen dramedy Freaks and Geeks is stacked with a who's who of future Hollywood stars, establishing everyone from Seth Rogen and Jason Segal to Busy Philipps and Linda Cardellini. High school isn't supposed to last forever, but boy do I wish Freaks and Geeks had. - David Opie, freelance journalist.

Dickensian

Two characters from Dickensian stand on a dimly lit Victorian street at night. A young man wears a burgundy frock coat over a patterned waistcoat and cravat, while beside him a woman is dressed in a striking purple Victorian gown with a white lace collar and cuffs. Both face the camera with serious expressions as warm gas lamps glow in the background.

Joseph Quinn as Arthur Havisham and Tuppence Middleton as Amelia Havisham. Red Planet Pictures

BBC drama Dickensian, created by Tony Jordan (EastEnders, Life on Mars), imagined what would happen if some of Charles Dickens's most iconic characters inhabited the same world, with their lives intertwining in unexpected ways.

It was an inherently fun, inventive premise, offering plenty of scope to build on Dickens's stories while subverting audience expectations.

But sadly, Dickensian lasted just one season before being cancelled – although, to be fair, that sole outing did span a sizeable 20 episodes.

Yet, its originality and ambition were admirable, and with some fine-tuning – a shorter first season and a tighter ensemble, for starters – it deserved the chance to grow into something even stronger. – Abby Robinson, Drama Editor.

Don't Trust the B in Apartment 23

A person with dark hair in a high bun and straight bangs stands at the counter of a modern coffee shop with their arms crossed, looking off to the side with a serious expression. They are wearing a cream-colored jacket, a black skirt, red lipstick, and large heart-shaped earrings. On the wooden counter are several bags of coffee beans, a glass pastry dome with pastries inside, a framed tipping notice, and a wallet. Behind them, blue subway-tile walls, coffee grinders, brewing equipment, and an espresso machine create the café setting, with a large coffee shop logo mounted on the back wall.

Krysten Ritter as Chloe. Karen Neal/Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

Long before she was Marvel's Jessica Jones, fan-favourite actor Krysten Ritter played an even more unpredictable antihero in this short-lived sitcom.

Don't Trust the B begins when wholesome Midwestern graduate June (Dreama Walker) moves to New York City for a big job and, she hopes, an exciting new life. Joining a flat share with charismatic party girl Chloe (Ritter) seems like hitting the jackpot, until her stunningly sociopathic nature presents itself.

'Young people surviving in the big city' is an overused sitcom premise that could easily become stale, but Chloe is like a living stick of dynamite ready to blow each episode wildly off course. Meanwhile, the late James Van Der Beek pokes fun at his public image as a warped parody of himself.

Alas, a botched rollout by ABC and an arguably unmarketable title contributed to Don't Trust the B's axing after just two abbreviated seasons, sadly depriving us of many more twisted tales. - David Craig, Senior Drama Writer.

The Day Today

The logo for satirical news programme The Day Today, featuring a red globe encircled by blue rings with the title in bold white lettering across the centre.

The logo for The Day Today. BBC/YouTube

This show remains one of British comedy’s sharpest and strangest achievements. Created by brilliant Armando Iannucci and mercurial Chris Morris, it transformed the language of television news into a comedic parade of absurdist headlines, pompous presenters and confident graphics. This is where its brilliance lay, in how closely it copied the tone of serious broadcasting: ridiculous reports were delivered with deadpan authority. The cast was exceptional, with Steve Coogan’s outstanding Alan Partridge emerging alongside Rebecca Front, David Schneider, Doon Mackichan and Patrick Marber.

Sadly, only six episodes were ever made, though its influence has spread far beyond that single series, shaping satire and launching several major careers. Three decades on, it still feels audacious, unsettling and painfully accurate about the vanity, hysteria and theatricality of modern news. - Shem Law, Editor.

Maternal

The main cast of ITV's Maternal.

Lara Pulver as Catherine MacDiarmid, Parminder Nagra plays Dr Maryam Afridi and Lisa McGrillis as Dr Helen Cavendish. ITV

Whilst the first and only season of this very well-executed ITV medical drama didn’t leave on any major cliffhanger, there was certainly ample enough material for a continuation.

Grounded by the natural chemistry of Parminder Nagra (DI Ray), Lara Pulver (The Split) and Lisa McGrillis (Rivals), Maternal never danced around its topics. It plummeted us headfirst into the world of a post-pandemic national health service while excellently depicting the struggles that women face returning to work after having a baby.

Eliciting laughs, shock and empathy as we dug into each of these doctors' complicated lives, Maternal felt like it was just getting started and could’ve really continued spearheading necessary conversations around modern motherhood, friendship and the NHS. - Morgan Cormack, Drama Writer.

Firefly

The cast of Firefly in character aboard the show's eponymous spaceship

(L-R) Alan Tudyk, Gina Torres, Jewel Staite, Nathan Fillion, Morena Baccarin and Sean Maher star in Firefly. Universal Studios

Another cancellation that disappointed plenty of RT readers was Firefly.

Joss Whedon's sci-fi series, set 500 years in the future, stars Nathan Fillion as the captain of a transporter ship, whose crew live on the far reaches of a galaxy ruled by a dictatorship. But when two mysterious fugitives climb aboard, they find themselves on the regime's radar.

Despite attracting an enthusiastic following, Firefly lasted just one season before being cancelled in 2002 after disappointing ratings. But fans have long argued those low viewing figures were the result of poor marketing by Fox and inconsistent scheduling – and, if it had debuted in the streaming era, the show would have found a bigger audience and been given the chance to further explore its rich world and memorable characters.

Instead, fans got just 14 episodes – and the 2005 follow-up film, Serenity.

Shardlake

Arthur Hughes, Sean Bean and Anthony Boyle in Shardlake. Their heads hover over an image of a monk in an archway

Arthur Hughes, Sean Bean and Anthony Boyle in Shardlake. Disney+

Few dramas are as ripe for multi-season success as Shardlake. It fitted within the all-consuming murder mystery genre that every broadcaster craves, yet had a unique twist, blending in Tudor history. It was led by big-name stars like Sean Bean alongside up-and-coming, buzzy actors like Anthony Boyle. It also arrived with unanticipated poignancy, premiering days after the death of book author, CJ Sansom.

With six more novels to adapt, it could have become a regular Tudor treat. It’s therefore devastating that Disney+ cancelled Shardlake after one season, given how dramatically compelling, visually arresting and all-round entertaining the four-parter was. - James Hibbs, Drama Writer.

The OA

Brit Marling and Jason Isaacs in The OA (Netflix)

Brit Marling and Jason Isaacs in The OA. Netflix

Brit Marling and Zal Batmanglij’s mind-bending sci-fi series for Netflix was complicated, attention-demanding, and challenging - but it was completely worth all the attention (and praise) it got when it first launched in 2016. The story follows a young woman, Prairie (Marling), who returns after being missing for seven years, and is no longer blind, and now calls herself The OA (Original Angel). She has the power to jump between dimensions, heal the sick, and more - powers which some try to abuse, naturally.

What made The OA so interesting, was that it wasn’t afraid to take us to narratively challenging places, flipping time and genre conventions on their heads while bringing viewers something genuinely fresh. The frankly criminal decision to end production after season 2 was made worse by the epic cliffhanger which saw Prairie enter a new dimension, where actor Jason Isaacs was himself, not the villainous Hap, and Prairie was now Brit, not the character. The show had the possibility to go anywhere, but instead left us with more unanswered questions than viewers should care for - and is still the reason to this day that fans beg Netflix to continue the show and close the ambitious story in a satisfying way. - Helen Daly, Associate Editor.

Virdee

Staz Nair as Harry Virdee in Virdee in a jacket at night

Staz Nair as Harry Virdee in Virdee. BBC / Magical Society

Detective dramas rarely deliver on action and heart in equal supply, but Virdee seamlessly managed to. From the slick Bond-like opening where we were introduced to Harry Virdee (Staz Nair), this Bradford-based drama instantly felt like something special for the BBC. With a South Asian-led cast and a central premise that revolved around love, interfaith marriage and prejudice, Virdee was unlike anything within the TV genre – especially as it was bookended by blockbuster-style twists.

Seeing as things reached fever pitch by the finale, it’s a true shame that creator AA Dhand’s vision couldn’t continue as the first season lay the foundations for a spectacular follow up. - Morgan Cormack, Drama Writer.

Santa Clarita Diet

Drew Barrymore stars in Santa Clarita Diet on Netflix

Drew Barrymore stars in Santa Clarita Diet. Netflix

Drew Barrymore's daytime chat show seems to be taking up most of her time now, but it's a somewhat deflating departure from the edgier work that she was doing right before.

Santa Clarita Diet chronicles the bizarre events that ensue when estate agent Sheila Hammond (Barrymore) realises she has become a zombie with an insatiable appetite for living flesh. Her highly strung husband Joel (Timothy Olyphant) soon becomes her partner-in-crime, concocting risky schemes to keep Sheila fed – without attracting the attention of the nosy cop next door.

Produced by Zombieland's Ruben Fleischer and Project Hail Mary's Chris Miller, Santa Clarita Diet was a delirious delight, which found ways to up the ante in each of its three seasons – before ending on an unresolved cliffhanger, courtesy of Netflix's notoriously strict viewership targets.

All these years later, it's still hard to believe that Barrymore, the famously placid chat show host, is the same person who did *that* to Nathan Fillion's finger. If you know, you know. - David Craig, Senior Drama Writer.

Holby City

Holby City cast

Holby City cast. BBC

Following a 23-year run, which far outstrips the lifespan of most cancelled shows, the BBC medical drama, which followed the comings and goings at the fictional Holby City Hospital, reached the end of the road in 2022.

"We sometimes have to make difficult decisions to make room for new opportunities and as part of the BBC's commitment to make more programmes across the UK, we have taken the difficult decision to bring the show to a close in order to reshape the BBC's drama slate to better reflect, represent and serve all parts of the country," read a statement shared by the broadcaster.

That news prompted a fan petition demanding the BBC reverse its decision, which racked up more than 43,000 signatures.

"Holby City has challenged the outlook in so many occasions and brought in so many great actors it will be a huge shame to end this program," it read, with the show often praised for raising awareness of health conditions and the pressures faced by the NHS in an accessible way.

For many, including RT readers. it wasn't simply a piece of entertainment best enjoyed with their tea. It provided a vital public service.

Ad

Check out more of our Drama coverage or visit our TV Guide and Streaming Guide to find out what's on. For more TV recommendations and reviews, listen to The Radio Times Podcast.

Authors

A head and shoulders shot of Abby Robinson. She is in front of a grey background, looking at the camera and smiling. She wears a black zipped-up jacket with an elaborate gold and maroon design

Abby RobinsonDrama Editor

Abby Robinson is the Drama Editor for Radio Times, covering TV drama and comedy titles. She previously worked at Digital Spy as a TV writer, and as a content writer at Mumsnet. She possesses a postgraduate diploma and a degree in English Studies.

Ad

Ad

Get the Christmas double issue

Too much to watch at Christmas? Let Radio Times do the choosing to find something the whole family will enjoy.

Subscribe by 3 Dec

Loading...

Ad

Loading...