- Home
- TV
- Drama
- Who will be Poirot's nemesis in the BBC's upcoming Hercule? We investigated the prime suspects from Agatha Christie's books
❚ We may earn commission from links on this page. Our editorial is always independent (learn more).
Who will be Poirot's nemesis in the BBC's upcoming Hercule? We investigated the prime suspects from Agatha Christie's books
Radio Times breaks down the contenders – and our picks for who should play them.

Mammoth Screen / Jonathan Ford
- Michael Hogan
Published: Thursday, 13 August 2026 at 11:00 am
Subscribe to Radio Times: 10 weeks for £10, including the Christmas double issue
Anticipation and speculation are building for the BBC’s upcoming Poirot prequel series, titled Hercule and starring Edward Bluemel as the iconic Belgian sleuth during his early years. Will it prove a young detective hit to rival Endeavour? Or will it have Agatha Christie spinning in her grave?
Ad
The six-part drama will be based on three of Christie’s early stories and set in London between the wars.
However, our keen investigative eye was caught by a mention in the latest Beeb blurb of the young Poirot being "introduced to future friends and allies – and one particular nemesis". To whom could this refer?
We’ve opened our casebook and exercised our "little grey cells" to work out which characters from the Queen of Crime’s original whodunits would fit the bill.
Here’s our round-up of the nine prime suspects – complete with casting suggestions for the actors who could play them.
1. Countess Vera Rossakoff

Ella Purnell stars as Rhiannon in Sweetpea. Sky
This glamorous Russian aristocrat moonlights as a jewel thief and pulls off the rare feat of outwitting Poirot. In The Double Clue, the dangerous, devious Countess is blackmailed into working for the "Big Four" crime cartel due to fears for her son’s safety. Poirot’s admiration for her ingenuity saw the flamboyant, fur-draped figure go from foe to friend and even unrequited crush – the cerebral sleuth’s only acknowledged love interest.
Indeed, they almost (gasp!) kiss in short story The Capture of Cerberus. She pops up in several more adventures and in One, Two, Buckle My Shoes, Poirot wonders if any woman can "hold a candle" to her. Think Irene Adler to Sherlock Holmes. Her appearance in the prequel series would show a softer side of the eccentric Belgian.
Who could play her: Olivia Cooke (House of the Dragon), Jessica Reynolds (A Woman of Substance) or Ella Purnell (Fallout).
2. Lanfranco Cassetti (aka Samuel Ratchett)

Luke Pasqualino as Bas Baddingham in Rivals. Disney+
"I’m a rich man, Mr Poirot. I have enemies." "I will not take your case because I do not like your face." The main antagonist of Murder on the Orient Express initially appears to be an American businessman who is spooked by death threats and tries to hire Poirot for protection.
However, he’s soon unmasked as fugitive Cassetti – a notorious gangster, kidnapper, blackmailer and child killer who is stabbed on the long-distance luxury train by vengeful loved ones of his victims. Cassetti is so ruthless and repulsive that Poirot decides not to report his killers to the police. Perhaps Poirot could meet the young Cassetti as a budding Mafioso in Soho.
Who could play him: Luke Pasqualino (Rivals) or Enzo Cilenti (I Fought the Law) have the requisite Italian heritage.
3. Stephen Norton (aka Mr X)

George MacKay and Tilda Swinton in The End. Sky
In Curtain: Poirot’s Last Case, the sleuth suspects that someone at a country house hotel was involved in five previous murders and is about to commit a sixth. To Captain Hastings's annoyance, Poirot won’t share their name, calling them only "X".
The murderous puppet master turns out to be this sickly, stammering, seemingly harmless birdwatcher. Norton never gets his own hands dirty but instead deploys psychological manipulation and the power of suggestion on his victims, manipulating them into killing while he gets away scot-free. A particularly sick and twisted villain, even by Christie’s standards.
Want to see this content?
This page contains content provided by Google reCAPTCHA. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as Google reCAPTCHA may use cookies and other technologies. To view this content, choose 'Accept and continue' to allow Google reCAPTCHA and its required purposes.
Accept and continue
Since Norton is Poirot’s opponent in his final case, his appearance in the prequel would have a neat circularity to it.
Who could play him: Joseph Quinn (Fantastic Four: First Steps), Fionn Whitehead (Great Expectations) or George MacKay (I Came By).
4. Magdala "Nick" Buckley

Jessica Raine as Zoe in Two Weeks in August. Various Artists Ltd/BBC/Robert Viglasky
In the fiendishly plotted Peril at End House, seductive Cornwall socialite Nick persuades Poirot that someone is out to kill her and she needs protecting. When a murder indeed takes place, she appears to be the intended victim – before being unmasked as the true killer. In between, Poirot toys with her to root out other criminals in their midst.
Envious, manipulative and diabolically clever, Buckley is a real piece of work who kills her own cousin for her fortune and tries to frame a friend. It would be fascinating to see her formative years.
Who could play her: Jenna Coleman (The Jetty) or Jessica Raine (Two Weeks in August) would fit the bill.
5. Dr James Sheppard

Nabhaan Rizwan in Agatha Christie's Seven Dials. Simon Ridgway/Netflix
In The Murder of Roger Ackroyd – widely hailed as Christie’s best and most groundbreaking Poirot story – the local physician appears as a key witness and the story's narrator, seemingly as a a stand-in for the sleuth’s usual sidekick, Captain Hastings.
That is, until the masterpiece’s famous plot twist. His honourable side and clear affection for his unmarried sister make Sheppard more sympathetic than most Christie antagonists. A youthful version popping up in a prequel would go down well with Christie buffs.
Who could play him: Connor Swindells (SAS Rogue Heroes) or Nabhaan Rizwan (Seven Dials).
6. Patrick and Christine Redfern

Marisa Abela as Yasmin in Industry. BBC/Bad Wolf Productions/HBO/Simon Ridgway
The psychopathic conman from Evil Under the Sun is among one of the most dangerous foes Poirot ever encountered.
At a swanky hotel in Devon – relocated to an even swankier Adriatic resort for the 1982 film starring Peter Ustinov – Redfern conspires with his wife Christine to heartlessly seduce young women and murder them for their fortunes, before elaborately covering up the crimes.
As if this wasn’t evil enough, he attempted to attack Poirot once he was cornered. It could be fun for the detective to encounter the dastardly couple as young newlyweds.
Who could play them: How about Industry pair Harry Lawtey and Marisa Abela?
7. Ariadne Oliver

Cush Jumbo in Criminal Record. Apple TV
More of a friend than a foe but it needn’t have always been that way. A crime novelist who created fictional Finnish detective Sven Hjerson, "Mrs Oliver" occasionally assists Poirot with her "feminine intuition” and insights into the criminal mind.
She appears in a clutch of Christie’s stories as comic relief. A clear self-parody, the recurring character enabled Christie to playfully send herself up. The prequel could see young Poirot run into the aspiring writer and sparks fly.
Who could play her: Cush Jumbo (Criminal Record), Ella Bruccoleri (The Other Bennet Sister) or Charlotte Ritchie (You).
8. Franklin Clarke

Anthony Boyle as Arthur Guinness in House of Guinness. Netflix
The ABC Murders sees a serial killer targeting unconnected strangers with alliterative names. Or does it? The so-called ABC Killer is actually aggrieved, embittered Clarke, who beats his wealthy elder brother to death for his inheritance and only commits the other crimes to disguise it as part of a killing spree.
He’s brazen enough to join the investigative team and frame an innocent man, mentally tormenting him into believing he must be guilty. A spiteful sociopath who taunts the ageing Poirot to satisfy his ego, Franklin is a haunting figure. A youthful cameo could hint at how he became so cruel.
Who could play him: Anthony Boyle (House of Guinness) or Leo Woodall (Bridget Jones: Mad About the Boy).
9. Miss Marple

Tamsin Greig as Natasha Groves in Suspect season 2 Channel 4 / Toon Aerts
Well, it’s made clear in the books that Christie’s two signature creations, Poirot and Marple, exist in the same fictional universe. Perhaps a prequel is a chance for the pair to meet at last?
Who could play her: Let’s aim high with Michelle Dockery (Downton Abbey), Tamsin Greig (Riot Women) or Phoebe Waller-Bridge (Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny).
Radio Times' verdict: Countess Vera Rossakoff
An intriguing rogues' gallery of suspects but we predict that Countess Vera Rossakoff will be the nemesis teased by the BBC. The chic, charismatic jewel thief would add some female presence and even a frisson of flirtation to the detective drama. Now all that remains is to see who plays her – and to watch the sparks fly.
Hercule is coming soon to BBC One and iPlayer.
Add shows to your watchlist on the Radio Times: What to Watch app – download now for daily TV recommendations, features and more.
Ad
Check out more of our Drama coverage or visit our TV Guide and Streaming Guide to find out what's on. For more TV recommendations and reviews, listen to The Radio Times Podcast.
Authors
Michael Hogan
Ad
Ad
Get the Christmas double issue
Too much to watch at Christmas? Let Radio Times do the choosing to find something the whole family will enjoy.
Loading...
Ad
Loading...
