- Home
- Movies
- We asked 4,000 film fans to name the saddest movie death of all time – and their childhood memories revealed a tragic pattern
❚ We may earn commission from links on this page. Our editorial is always independent (learn more).
We asked 4,000 film fans to name the saddest movie death of all time – and their childhood memories revealed a tragic pattern
From Up to The Green Mile, which devastating moment came out on top with Radio Times readers?

Disney
- Molly Moss
Published: Thursday, 19 November 2026 at 12:00 pm
Subscribe to Radio Times: 10 weeks for £10, including the Christmas double issue
From heartbreaking separations (yes, we’re thinking of Dumbo) and emotional reunions, to devastating moments of unrequited love and heartbreak (Call Me by Your Name, anyone?), movies certainly have the power to make us sad.
Ad
But few moments are quite as heartbreaking as the death of a beloved character.
These scenes can stay with us long after the credits have rolled, lingering in our memories for years – particularly if they were our first introduction to mortality as children...
But which movie death has destroyed audiences the most over the years?
We put that question to Radio Times followers on Facebook and received more than 4,000 comments.
One theme that appeared time and time again was animal deaths, with viewers describing how the demise of canine friends in films such as Marley & Me, Bambi and The NeverEnding Story left them heartbroken.
But which movie got the most mentions? Read on for a list of the top 10 saddest movie deaths of all time, according to Radio Times readers.
10. Dobby – Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1

Dobby in Harry Potter.
Coming in at 10th place are the Harry Potter films, which are brimming with upsetting death scenes from start to finish.
Dumbledore’s death at the hands of Snape in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince received multiple mentions from our readers, and it’s easy to see why: it’s an emotional moment as he meets his fate with weary, sorrowful acceptance.
Professor Snape’s demise in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 also struck a chord with our readers, with many pointing out that it was even more poignant as he was revealed to be a tragic hero of circumstance.
But it's Dobby's death that is perhaps the most tragic across the Harry Potter films.
The character dies in Harry’s arms in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1 after being stabbed by Bellatrix Lestrange while attempting to save Harry and his friends from Malfoy Mansion.
9. Hillary Whitney – Beaches

Barbara Hershey and Bette Midler in Beaches. Hulton Archive / Getty Images
Gary Marshall’s 1988 film Beaches is coming in at ninth place. The drama tells the story of two yin-and-yang women, Hillary Whitney (played by Barbara Hershey) and CC Bloom (played by Bette Midler), and their lifelong friendship.
However, their bond is brought to an abrupt end at the end of the film when Hillary dies surrounded by Bloom and her daughter, Victoria (Grace Johnston), while the power ballad Wind Beneath My Wings plays over the top.
It’s a tear-jerking scene and, more than 30 years after the film’s release, the moment still lingers in the memories of many of our readers.
"Beaches, when the little girl asks if she can bring her cat with her - as if the friend passing away wasn't bad enough !!! Floods of tears!!" one reader wrote, referring to the moment where Victoria asks if she can bring her cat, Pouncer, when CC tells her she can move in with her following the death of her mother.
8. Thomas J – My Girl

Macauley Culkin as Thomas in My Girl. Sony Pictures Entertainment/ YouTube
Coming in at eighth place is My Girl, the 1991 coming-of-age story following Vada Sultenfuss (Anna Chlumsky) as she navigates the complexities of growing up in the 1970s.
The quaint comedy takes an unexpectedly morbid turn when Thomas J (Macaulay Culkin) – who is allergic to bee stings – dies in a devastating twist after he accidentally stumbles into a smashed beehive while trying to retrieve his best friend’s lost mood ring.
The plot development marks a sharp tonal shift, and one that divided critics, but one that has certainly stayed in the minds of many viewers.
7. Artax – The NeverEnding Story

Noah Hathaway as Atreyu in The NeverEnding story. Warner Bros. Pictures/ YouTube
Next up is Wolfgang Petersen's 1984 fantasy adventure The NeverEnding Story, which featured a death scene that is agonising to watch – the demise of Artax, the gallant white horse, who perishes after he’s led into the Swamp of Sadness by the hero Atreyu.
While Atreyu is protected from the swamp, Artax has no such luck and is soon taken over by depressive thoughts and hopelessness. It’s a devastating scene as he sinks into the darkness, while Atreyu tries to save him.
"I was sobbing for weeks! Okay I was like 8 but still. It really affected me,” one reader said.
Another reader added: “Artax… The white horse in never ending story - still don’t think I've recovered properly.”
6. Ellie – Up

Carl in Up. Pixar/ YouTube
Sixth on the list is Pixar’s 2009 film Up, which follows Carl Fredricksen, a 78-year-old retired balloon salesman who is determined to get to South America to keep a promise he made to his late wife, Ellie.
The film begins with flashback scenes showing the couple's adventures over the years. We see the pair grow up, fall in love, get married and move in together. But then Ellie collapses and passes away and, when we cut back to the present day, Carl is all alone in the house. It’s hard to get through the heart-wrenching scene without tears.
One reader said of the film: "I firmly believe that if you don't cry watching the first 10 minutes of UP .. then you are not even human."
5. Yeller – Old Yeller

Yeller in Old Yeller. Walt Disney/ YouTube
Coming in at fifth place is 1957 Disney movie Old Yeller, which tells the story of a family in Texas in 1869 that adopts a lovable stray dog.
Tragically, however, the family’s bond with the dog is short-lived. In a heartbreaking scene, the father has no choice but to shoot and kill Yeller to end its suffering and protect his family after the dog contracts rabies.
One reader wrote in the comments: "Old Yeller......I saw the film as a child, and it traumatised me for years. Couldn't watch it now."
4. Coffey – The Green Mile

Michael Clarke Duncan as John Coffey in The Green Mile. Warner Bros. Entertainment/ YouTube
Another death mentioned by many of our readers is that of John Coffey (Michael Clarke Duncan) in the 1999 movie The Green Mile.
Coffey is executed at the end of the film for crimes that it has become clear he didn’t commit.
It’s a heartbreaking scene as the character comes to terms with the injustice of his death and makes no attempt to resist it.
"Green Mile. The book is actually worse. Blubbering wreck laid on a sunbed on holiday,” one reader wrote.
3. Bambi's mother - Bambi

Bambi.
Coming in at fourth on the list is the 1942 coming-of-age Disney movie Bambi, which tells the story of a young fawn raised by his mother in the wilderness before tragedy strikes.
The film’s most harrowing scene sees a hunter shoot and kill Bambi’s mother, while Bambi narrowly escapes. It marks the end of Bambi’s childhood as, from then on, he must learn to survive on his own.
It’s a genuinely heart-wrenching scene and, as the comments from our readers show, one that serves as the earliest introduction to mortality for many youngsters.
"My nanny took me to Leicester Square Odeon to see Bambi. I think I was 4 (now 71). I can remember the big comfortable seats and crying a lot,” one of our readers wrote.
2. Marley – Marley & Me

Owen Wilson in Marley & Me. 20th Century Studios./ YouTube
Taking the penultimate place on the list is another tragic passing of a furry friend on screen: that of Marley from 2008 film Marley & Me, which is based on the 2005 memoir by American journalist John Grogan about his family’s titular Labrador.
The tragic death occurs in the movie's finale as Marley is put down at the vet’s, with Grogan (Owen Wilson) standing by his side.
It is the rest of the film that makes this scene so heart-wrenching: seeing the huge impact the furry friend made on the lives of Grogan and his family and all the moments of joy he brings, only for it to come to an abrupt and tragic end.
1. Billy Flynn – The Champ

Ricky Schroder as Timothy and John Voight as Billy in The Champ. United Artists/ YouTube
And... top of the saddest deaths list according to our readers is the passing of Billy Flynn (Jon Voight) in Franco Zeffirelli’s 1979 Oscar-winning film The Champ.
The movie follows boxer Billy's attempts to make a comeback in the ring – a dream that he eventually goes on to achieve.
However, in a cruel twist of fate at the end of the movie, the character collapses from his injuries and dies in front of his young son.
The tragic nature of the scene is also heightened by the raw grief of the son, who tries to wake up his father and sobs: “Champ, wake up!”
One reader said of the scene: "Jon Voight in The Champ..How anybody cannot cry at the end is beyond me!!! In fact, I was incarcerated in the mid 80's, they put this on for us on film night, I saw hardened criminals shedding tears at the end!"
Ad
Check out more of our Film coverage or visit our TV Guide and Streaming Guide to find out what's on. For more TV recommendations and reviews, listen to The Radio Times Podcast.
Authors

Molly MossTrends Writer
Molly Moss is a Trends Writer for Radio Times, covering the latest trends across TV, film and more. She has an MA in Newspaper Journalism and has previously written for publications including The Guardian, The Times and The Sun Online.
Ad
Ad
Get the Christmas double issue
Too much to watch at Christmas? Let Radio Times do the choosing to find something the whole family will enjoy.
Loading...
Ad
Loading...
