- Home
- audio
- Radio
- BBC Radio 4 Extra remains exceptionally cheap to run and shows off priceless content we paid for – so why is it being shut down?
❚ We may earn commission from links on this page. Our editorial is always independent (learn more).
BBC Radio 4 Extra remains exceptionally cheap to run and shows off priceless content we paid for – so why is it being shut down?
A public campaign helped save 6 Music from BBC cuts – do we need another one to rescue Radio 4 Extra?

Peter Dazeley/Getty Images
- Caroline Frost
Published: Monday, 16 November 2026 at 5:00 pm
Subscribe to Radio Times: 10 weeks for £10, including the Christmas double issue
This article first appeared in Radio Times magazine.
Ad
Never before in my custodianship of the RT postbag has it been so inundated with letters on one topic – variously expressing the disappointment, frustration and even confusion of their writers, but all concerned with a single subject, namely the closure next spring of Radio 4 Extra.
We know the BBC has been charged with making a whopping £500 million worth of cuts, that it must somehow present itself as a slick, modern operator capable of sailing into the choppy waters of charter renewal next year, while competing with the big-budget streamers and somehow keeping all its different audiences happy, so something was going to have to give.
The plan to shut down BBC Three’s linear channel (again) raised barely an eyebrow among RT readers, but then why should it? Its youthful target audience seek their content online; for them, the linear channel isn’t the front door but a rusty drawbridge that could potentially even work against the brand as viewing habits continue to change.
Not so Radio 4 Extra, a station that since inception as BBC 7 in 2002 has become a treasure trove of classic BBC audio, comedy and drama. RT readers have mentioned everything from Hancock to The Goons, from Hinge and Bracket to Adrian Mole and the delight of an ancient Desert Island Discs. One correspondent describes “the station being switched on in the morning and moving with us throughout the house”.

Tony Hancock and Moira Lister on the Radio Times cover in 1954
The BBC’s boss of national speech radio, Jonathan Wall, disputes claims that this is a move to penalise listeners, mostly older, most likely to continue paying the licence fee despite losing their favourite station. But he’s under orders to save £12 million and closing Radio 4 Extra brings him £2-3m of that at a throw. When you consider that equates to roughly 90 minutes of drama on BBC One, those listeners may not be being penalised but they are, how should we say it, being disproportionately affected.
Wall promises 4 Extra listeners will get all the same joy out of BBC Sounds, but this overlooks two important aspects. Firstly, the archive will have to be reduced to make the savings needed; there is no guarantee of the current 600 hours available being replenished. Plus, this is simply not how radio works, particularly for the Extra audience.
For many, it’s more than a broadcaster, it’s a companion and also a fount of inspiration. One of our readers delights in “stories and plays that surprise me”, and RT editor Shem Law summed up the whole point of radio as “turning it on and hearing something you never knew you wanted”.
Want to see this content?
This page contains content provided by Google reCAPTCHA. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as Google reCAPTCHA may use cookies and other technologies. To view this content, choose 'Accept and continue' to allow Google reCAPTCHA and its required purposes.
Accept and continue
Because it relies on old material rather than commissioning new shows, even with its rights and talent-clearing costs, Radio 4 Extra remains exceptionally cheap to run, serving an audience of 1.4million at a cost of 0.6p per user hour (compared with, say, 5p for Radio 1 Extra). New director-general Matt Brittin has trumpeted the value of the BBC archive; it seems extraordinary that he wouldn’t want to put this cheap but beloved content at the front of his stall.
It seems a careless shot in one’s own foot to sit on this priceless archive, without investing in a thoughtful, proactive way of curating and presenting it to new listeners, while keeping that large, existing audience happy.
Finally, let’s not forget that we all paid for this content when it was made, back when the licence fee was a much more secure source of income, which meant programme commissioners could be bold, and creatives could be… creative, which is why we have Hancock, Hinge and Bracket and all those other vintage pleasures waiting to be unearthed on Radio 4 Extra – for now.
What to do? Well, take hope from the fact that 6 Music was once destined for a similar banging of the door, before a national campaign prompted a rethink. The loudest voices came from artists and fans of indie music, by definition a small but passionate group. Surely, a canon of our most classic comedy, drama and wider culture can summon up the same fervour?
The latest issue of Radio Times is out on Tuesday – subscribe here.

Ad
Check out more of our Audio coverage or visit our TV Guide and Streaming Guide to find out what's on. For more TV recommendations and reviews, listen to The Radio Times Podcast.
Authors
Caroline Frost
Ad
Ad
Get the Christmas double issue
Too much to watch at Christmas? Let Radio Times do the choosing to find something the whole family will enjoy.
Loading...
Ad
Loading...
