Inside Holmesburg Prison: How inmates were used for medical testing
The US officially sanctioned toxic and painful experiments on inmates, says Allen Hornblum

Gary Neil
- Bill Borrows
World of Secrets: Dr Skin is on Wednesday at 1.30pm/11.30pm on BBC World Service
Ad
The prisoners were overwhelmingly Black and Puerto Rican,” remembers Allen Hornblum of his first day inside Holmesburg Prison, Philadelphia, in 1971. “Scores of them had adhesive tape and bandages on their heads, backs, chests and arms. I thought there must have been some kind of gang war, but when I asked a guard, ‘What’s with all the bandages?’ he just laughed.”
Hornblum was an idealistic 23-year-old graduate, inspired by JFK’s 1961 inaugural speech (“Ask not what what your country can do for you – ask what you can do for your country”) to sign up to teach on the adult literacy programme within the US justice system.
“The next day I asked more questions. He said not to worry, it was to do with ‘the perfume test for the University of Pennsylvania’. It was a very hot September and the smells of the prison were nothing you’d associate with Arpège by Lanvin. I was told, ‘These inmates are desperate for money. If you push a broom, you’ll get 25 cents a day, but if you’re a test subject, you’ll make $1. The army experiments pay $2 a day.’”
Hornblum kept digging until he was warned, “You’re new here, the tests have been going on for 20 years. Keep asking and you’ll be kicked out.” He was convinced something untoward was taking place. One inmate told him he was just selling them a piece of his skin. “Occasionally, they’d take off a shirt and show me the patches on their back,” he tells Dr Skin, the latest series in the World Service’s World of Secrets strand. “They’d show me the scars.” It soon dawned on him that “the perfume test” was a cover for something much more sinister. He was inside, in his words, “the largest human experimentation factory in American history”.
The “Dr Skin” of the title is the late University of Pennsylvania dermatologist Dr Albert M Kligman, the co-inventor of acne treatment Retin-A. It was a nickname he cherished and even used it on his car licence plate.
Hornblum’s eyewitness account and subsequent investigation became a book published almost 20 years after he left the facility. It was called Acres of Skin: Human Experiments at Holmesburg Prison – the title coming from an expression Kligman enjoyed using while encouraging students to join his department: “Come to Penn, we have acres of skin.” The skin of the vulnerable, poorly educated inmates of Holmesburg Prison.
Kligman remained calm until I asked him about being compared with Josef Mengele
Kligman’s sinister, unregulated but officially sanctioned, multimillion dollar operation centred around medical procedures such as everyday patch tests and skin biopsies for mundane cosmetic products, but the prisoners were also exposed to experimental drugs and highly toxic chemical compounds on behalf of major pharmaceutical interests. “They put dioxin [as found in Agent Orange] on the inmates’ faces and backs and radioactive isotopes were injected into their shoulders and arms,” explains Hornblum. “But Kligman and his doctors kept that information to themselves.”
Although not entirely. When the US Army’s Chemical Corps needed a larger testing centre for Project Often, they knew the best-known dermatologist in America had an experimental control group away from public scrutiny. The perfect place to expand the classified research programme they were running alongside the CIA’s infamous MKUltra initiative into how certain chemical substances and experimental drugs affected the brain, nervous system and human behaviour.
“The inmates came back from testing wearing a tag stating, ‘Please disregard my appearance and behaviour. I’m part of the US Army Penn Medical Studies,’” says Hornblum. “They didn’t know their own name or where they were after being hit with high levels of [drugs designed to cause a chemical imbalance in the brain]. It threw a lot of them into serious depression and even changed their criminal orientation. Earlier they had been involved in non-violent offences; now they were doing stickups with weapons and beating up their wives and kids.” All for an extra $1 a day.
Kligman remained unrepentant about the nature of his work even after his “human experimentation factory” was closed in 1974. Despite court cases brought by former Holmesburg inmates and newspaper exposés throughout the 1970s and 80s, the professor remained insulated by his status, wealth and the connections made while undertaking “research” on behalf of at least 33 pharmaceutical and cosmetic companies, and the US Department of Defence.
It wasn’t until Acres of Skin appeared in 1998 that all the threads were pulled together. Hornblum even persuaded Kligman to talk. “I explained I’d worked inside the US justice system and been at Holmesburg at the same time and that worked,” smiles the author. “I put what I’d found out to him. He deflected most of it and even said he was sorry the experiments had had to end. He thought the city made a great mistake [by closing the programme].
“He remained calm and collected until I asked him what he felt about comparisons that were being drawn between him and Josef Mengele [the doctor at Auschwitz-Birkenau concentration camp who had experimented on prisoners]. He was very upset at the very mention of Mengele and came out forcefully. He said, ‘How could I be a Nazi doctor? I’m Jewish.’ He used that to deflect from the pain he had inflicted on thousands of people.”
Ad
Kligman died aged 93 in 2010 without facing justice during his lifetime, like Mengele who was never proscuted for his crimes. Yet since 2021 the University of Pennsylvania, the City of Philadelphia and the College of Physicians of Philadelphia have all formally apologised and revoked Kligman’s honours. Arguably, a case of too little, too late for the Holmesburg prisoners.
Authors
Bill Borrows
Ad
Ad
Get the Christmas double issue
Too much to watch at Christmas? Let Radio Times do the choosing to find something the whole family will enjoy.
Ad
