The X Factor 2012 rumour mill: will Robbie Williams be a judge?

Rotating guest judges might be just the gratuitous format change this year's show is crying out for

Comments
The X Factor 2012 rumour mill: will Robbie Williams be a judge?
Written By
Jack Seale

THE RUMOUR: Robbie Williams is to take time off from his increasingly relevant solo career to appear as a guest judge on the live shows. This "major revamp" of the format could see STARS also including Pink, Gwen Stefani and Bruno Mars take their turn as rotating JUDGES – in the sense that there'll be a different one each week, not on Voice-style spinning CHAIRS, although chairs that turn round surely can't be copyrighted. Presumably they'll either sit behind a specially extended desk or, in Bruno Mars's case, simply perch on somebody's knee. Later in the series, X Factor Independent Traders CEO Simon Cowell will himself return.

QUOTE FROM A "SOURCE" WHO PROBABLY DOESN'T EXIST: “The idea is to get the famous acts more involved in the show and the decision-making. They would be there to give their opinion as unbiased judges without having a vested interest in any of the acts. Producers know that having [Cowell] criticising and judging the other judges would be TV gold.” (Daily Star)

RADIOTIMES.COM TRUTH RATING: 3/5. Why not? Having guest judges very nearly kept this year's audition stages interesting and would give viewers something extra to talk about. Plus, it could spell a comeback for the refreshingly rude Mel B if someone famous drops out. And, five judges mean Louis Walsh can't send the final decision to deadlock, thus avoiding "fix" claims and helping Downton Abbey to start on time.

Add new comment

Ads by Google