The Amy Fisher Story

The Amy Fisher Story

Andy Tennant (1993)

15 Certificate


Our Score
Amy Fisher was a cause célèbre in the early 1990s and her case achieved a level of public notoriety that was unusual considering no one was actually killed. Fisher shot the wife of her older lover, and being a good-looking nymphette was prime front-page fodder, especially since the area in which the incident happened was Long Island. The scandal had repercussions: on three different US TV networks, three different made-for-TV movies of the case premiered within six days of each other, and this one is by far the best of the batch, with Drew Barrymore in Bad Girls mode as the sexpot Amy, and Anthony John Denison as her lover, one Joey Buttafuoco. The tale is told here, Rashomon-style, from differing points of view, but it's still a pretty sleazy story.


A teenager assaults her alleged older lover's wife, and becomes a media sensation at the subsequent trial. Fact-based drama exploring the intimate details of the case, starring Drew Barrymore, Anthony John Denison and Harley Jane Kozak.

Cast & Crew

Amy Fisher Drew Barrymore
Joey Buttafuoco Anthony John Denison
Amy Pagnozzi Harley Jane Kozak
Mary Jo Buttafuoco Laurie Paton
Roseann Fisher Linda Darlow
Elliot Fisher Ken Pogue
Director Andy Tennant
see more

Other Information

Language: EnglishColourAvailable on: video