Saturday 21 November

BLOGS

blogCategory
Previous
Back to blog
Next

The Best...medical drama

Maura Tierney as Abby
  • Posted at 1:13pm
  • 04 October 2006
  • by DavidBrown-RT
  • 4 comments

After 12 years of watching ER, I still have no idea what a "C-spine, chem 7, CBC, chest film and blood gas" is, but it sure as hell makes me feel like I'm eavesdropping on the way things work in a city-centre American A&E.

No other medical show has taken such a risk with its audience as ER. Despite the soap opera ethics, scenes of wholesale slaughter and moral dilemmas, its intense medical realism means that only a small percentage of the audience is likely to understand exactly what's going on. So what makes it so highly addictive?

Certainly, it doesn't skimp on the action. We've had an outbreak of smallpox, a "lockdown" quarantine and a shootout by armed criminals. All in the one hospital. And that's not counting Dr Luca Kovac being able to sleep with every female staff member, plus veteran nurse Haleh's amazing nine-stone weight loss between seasons.

It's also gone through more cast changes than Blue Peter, with each new doctor bringing their personal crises into the arena of medical chaos. In fact, the only thing missing these days is a boo-hiss villain you pray will get electrocuted by their own defibrillator paddles, at least now that Kerry Weaver has gone all soft and "Rocket" Romano's been flattened by a falling helicopter.

But it's the level of sophistication on ER that makes it stand out from the crowd. Take the BBC's Casualty for instance: a drama still reliant on acting that comes straight out of a Crimewatch reconstruction, nurse manager Charlie Fairhead's middle-distance staring, a lot of extended sighing to end scenes and moments on the ward where staff members really lose it in front of all their colleagues.

To show just how little things have changed since 1986, the opening episode of the latest series of Casualty (Saturday 24 September) even had one of those formulaic and uninspired large-scale calamities (in this case a bus crash) that should have been signposted with "beware - big, yet unambitious, set piece" flashing on-screen.

Whatever the accident - a lorry exploding, a nuclear waste spillage - it always has the dramatic resonance of a Public Information film and the pace of an elderly lady on her way to the shops. Someone slap a DNR notice on it, please.

In ER, there's no time for long sighs and staring. Not with all the long steadicam shots, breakneck editing and sub-plot upon sub-plot that feature in almost every episode. Yet characters are still given space to evolve, sometimes over the course of years.

Take Dr Carter's growth from naive med student to overseas aid worker, or Dr Greene's post-traumatic stress following his assault. These things have unfolded with care and attention, but also blended effortlessly with the split-second decision-making in the workplace.

Hectic, relentless, intense and authentic, ER is indispensable TV. It raised the bar where medical drama is concerned and still leaves the rest looking in need of a shot in the arm.

Link to this post
Post a comment | 4 comments

Comments

  • Posted on 29 August 2009
  • at 6:40pm
  • by Noel

Loved ER however it seemed like I was the only one in the UK that felt that way. Best medical drama and just a great drama series generally. It made you care about its characters

  • Posted on 10 June 2009
  • at 12:56pm
  • by deep
best medical drama ever! ever!
  • Posted on 08 January 2009
  • at 8:19pm
  • by Katie McGregor

I can't believe no-one has commented on this before. Maybe it's because it's so self-evidently true. ER will be missed.

  • Posted on 04 October 2006
  • at 9:10pm
  • by Gillian

Finally someone has recognised how amazing ER really is! So thank you! I've been watching for a couple of years and have managed to get my friend hooked as well!! I love the fast pace action, not, as you say, like casualty, where you've got the granny at the top of the steps with a bag of potatoes and then, OH NO, the potatoes split the bag and the lady slips over and bangs her head. Now that's drama- NOT! If you're looking for action, then ER is the place to go.

At the moment, Ray is the best character (played by Shane West), i just hope he doesnt leave anytime soon!

For sneeky peaks about what's going to happen next season go to www.nbc.com/ER and cheat!!

Post a comment

Do you have something to say about this post? Share your thoughts…

Post a comment

(first or nickname only)

Please do not include any personal or personally identifiable information about yourself or others (including email addresses). All information you submit about yourself or others can be viewed by others.

Thank you for your comment

Thank you for your comments. All comments will be looked at by a moderator, however, due to the numbers of comments we receive, we can't promise that all will be posted on the site.

Post another comment

More


Advertisement